Forecasting the value of historical cold weapons




cultural monuments, cold weapons, identification, commodity evaluation, expert evaluation, attribution, value prediction, comparative method.


The question of the assessment of cultural monuments, including the assessment of losses caused to Ukrainian museums, archives, foundations, and private collectors due to the Russian military aggression, is urgent and extremely important for owners and managers. It is related to the need to determine the appraised value in numerous court cases about lost, damaged, or stolen property, as well as the legality of the transfer of property rights and the determination of insurance amounts. For commodification evaluation, professional apprai­sers and forensic experts need objective, unified and computerized methods of recognizing cultural monuments, particularly cold weapons, for further evalua­tion. This makes it possible to use available information sources and specialized databases to identify and assess the affinity of examina­tion objects, to calculate the approximate estimated value of samples of cold weapons.

The development of a specialized algorithm for determining the value of lost and destroyed cultural values, in particular cold weapons, is gaining relevance.

Since it is difficult for experts and collectors to form the value of lots, taking into account the constant change and unsystematic information about antique cold weapons, the task of the research is to improve the methodology, which will at least partially solve the above-described problem.

The result of the conducted research is an improved technique for evaluating cold weapons, which will significantly simplify the procedures for assessing auction lots and items from museum and private collections.

Author Biography

Taras KARAVAEV, State University of Trade and Economics

Doctor of Technical Sciences, Professor, Professor of the Department of Commodity Studies and Customs Affairs


Indutnyj, V., Merezhko, N., & Pirkovich, K. (2017). Safety of cultural monuments made of metals. International scientific and practical journal "Commodities and Markets", 1(23), 36-49.

Indutnyj, V. (2016). Assessment of cultural values. Kyiv National University of Trade and Economics.

Indutnyj, V., Merezhko, N., & Toi'chkin, D. (2017). Merchandising characteristics of antique cold weapons on the market of Ukraine. Scientific works. "History of Ancient Weapons" Research 2016, 323-337.

Indutnyj, V., Kravec', A., & Vovk, Ju. (2019). Forecasting the value of antique cold weapons by a comparative method. Evaluation Bulletin, 4(57), 59-69.

Vovk, Y. (2020). Predicting the cost of antique cold weapons by a comparative method. The International Scientific-Practical Journal "Commodities and Markets", 34(2), 46-57.

violity. (n. d.). Auction for collectors.

Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine "On approval of National standard № 1 "General principles of valuation of property and property rights" № 1440 (2022).п#Text

Law of Ukraine "On valuation of property, property rights and professional valuation activity in Ukraine" № 2658-III (2023).

Order of the Ministry of Culture and Arts of Ukraine "On approval of the Instruction on the procedure for determining the estimated and insurance value of monuments of the Museum Fund of Ukraine" № 325 (2002).

Shalev, S., Shechtman, D., & Shilstein, S. (2013). Studies on the composition and microstructure of silver hoards from Tel Bet Shean, Tel Dor, and Tel Mikneh, Israel. Bulletin of Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 6(3), 221-225.

Conventi, A., Neri, E., & Verità, M. (2012). SEM-EDS analysis of ancient gold leaf glass mosaic tesserae. A contribution to the dating of the materials. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 32(1), 012007.



How to Cite

KARAVAEV Т. (2023). Forecasting the value of historical cold weapons. Commodities·and·markets, 47(3), 111–124.